12 January 2015
Loch
Lomond & The Trossachs National Park Authority statement on Your Park
consultation
The debate sparked over the
weekend on the Your Park consultation has shown that there are strongly held
views on all sides and the deadline for the end of the public consultation is
midnight Monday 12 January 2015.
Loch Lomond & the
Trossachs National Park Authority has a statutory responsibility for striking a
balance between conservation, rural development and visitor experience in one
of Scotland’s most sensitive and visited landscapes.
The Your Park consultation has
been actively encouraging all who live in and use the Park to offer their views
on the proposals to introduce a new suite of measures, including camping
provision and camping byelaws to some hot spots around the Park, in order to
help ease the environmental damage and reduce the antisocial behaviour of some
irresponsible campers.
The formal consultation on the
Your Park proposals to introduce a package of measures similar to east Loch
Lomond, which, in total, will affect less than 5% of the National Park where
camping pressures are worst, was launched on October 13 and runs until midnight
on Monday, January 12.
In the 12 years since the
National Park was established, its work has focussed on the fine line between
promoting access and enjoyment and protecting the environment and the
communities that live and work in what is by far the busiest areas of
countryside in Scotland during summer months.
In response to some misleading
statements which have appeared in media in the last few days.
Gordon Watson, Director of
Operations at Loch Lomond & the Trossachs National Park who takes up the
post of Chief Executive next week, has published a blog. He said;
“We understand that there is
strong feeling on the part of outdoors enthusiasts about their ‘right to roam’.
However, some of the arguments presented seem intent on downplaying the
atrocious damage that is being caused to the environment of a National Park, as
well as the impact on residents and visitors. Enforcement of existing law
already happens with significant resources going into Operation Ironworks
police enforcement, but this is not deterring the problems as byelaws have done
on east Loch Lomond.
“The many residents and
visitors affected by these problems are impatient for action and rightly expect
us to come up with effective solutions. The National Park (Scotland) Act 2000 gives
us byelaw-making powers for a reason; we are expected to protect the
environment from damaging overuse and abuse. The package of measures we are
proposing combines investing
in more informal low cost camping facilities, continuing education initiatives
as well as introducing controls on the amount of camping.
“The Your Park proposals which
are out to public consultation currently build on the successful measures
introduced at east Loch Lomond and, again, have been the subject of widespread,
informal consultation with local partners, national bodies, outdoor recreation
organisations, public and private landowners, local communities and businesses.
“The assertion that the
byelaws haven’t worked and that the figure of 81% reduction in antisocial
behaviour (asb) crimes is inaccurate, is based on (now retired) Kevin
Findlater’s personal response to the consultation which has been taken at face
value.
“As Chief Inspector
responsible for policing in the Park when the byelaws at east Loch Lomond were
introduced, Kevin Findlater supported their introduction and furthermore
produced the figure of 81.5%, which featured in Central Scotland Police’s
Operation Ironworks evaluation report 2009-2012.”
Kevin
Lilburn, local resident and chair of the East Loch Lomond Visitor Management
Group adds:
"Previously
we suffered some sort of incident at my home pretty much every weekend in the
summer, including litter, theft, vandalism and verbal or even physical
intimidation. Since the byelaws have been introduced, there have been
none. Not one. That speaks for itself and official statistics tell a
similar story. We have gone from a situation where my neighbours and I
dreaded sunny days to one in which we can relax, enjoy where we live, and
happily share the area with responsibly behaved visitors.”
Mr Findlater's views are not
shared by Police Scotland, whose officers have accumulated significant
experience of the issues on the ground working alongside the National Park. In
a statement releases last Friday, Police Scotland Divisional Commander, Davie
Flynn, said:
“We have enjoyed a
longstanding positive relationship with Loch Lomond & the Trossachs
National Park including the coordinated, successful approach we have been
taking to tackle antisocial behaviour crimes, vandalism and littering at east
Loch Lomond.
“Police Scotland is generally
supportive of the introduction of a byelaw replicating the purpose and spirit
of the existing east Loch Lomond byelaw in other parts of the National Park
where visitor pressure, crime and antisocial behaviour is affecting safety,
quality of life and the environment. This support extends only when implemented
as part of a suite of wider measures such as those introduced from 2011 in east
Loch Lomond.”
Mr Watson concludes by
stating:
“Far from being cynical or
shameful, it’s our daily duty, and honour, to take care of this special place,
and the proposals we’ve made in Your Park, have at their heart the best
interests of the Park and the people who cherish and enjoy it.
We welcome and will consider
all responses fully and carefully in making our final recommendations to our
Board who, in turn, will advise Scottish Government.”
Those wishing to register
their views are encouraged to so by visiting http://www.thisisyourpark.org.uk before
the deadline of Monday 12 January 2015.
-ENDS-
Issued by the BIG
Partnership on behalf of Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park
Authority.
For further information or
interviews with Gordon Watson or Kevin Lilburn, please contact;
Kelly Paterson
T: 0141 333 9585 M: 07882
152 914
E: Kelly.Paterson@bigpartnership.co.uk
OR Nancy McLardie, PR and
Media Manager, Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park on 01389 722016 or
07834 334108.
Notes to editors:
To view Gordon Watson’s blog addressing the main issues at
play in the Your Park consultation posted yesterday evening, visit http://www.thisisyourpark.org.uk/the-real-situation-on-the-ground/
East Loch Lomond suffered most acutely. The Park Authority
worked with local partners, national bodies, outdoor recreation organisations,
public and private landowners, as well as local communities and businesses to
try to arrive at a solution.
The Operation Ironworks initiative was the initial response,
established more than seven years ago in conjunction with Central Scotland
Police (now Police Scotland), to minimise and mitigate against the behaviour of
those who were behaving irresponsibly.
This included investing in additional Police patrols on busy
weekends and a dedicated National Park Police Officer to help coordinate this.
This allows us to respond quickly to situations and to ensure prosecutions
using existing laws.
The former Chief Inspector of Central Scotland Police, Kevin
Findlater, presided over this, but a few years later decided in conjunction
with all partners that a more rigorous approach was needed and approved the introduction
of a suite of measures at east Loch Lomond including a byelaw to manage
camping.
The byelaw at east Loch Lomond came into effect on June 1
2011 and by 2012, Kevin Findlater himself was celebrating its success, quoting
statistics from Central Scotland Police’s ‘Operation Ironworks’ evaluation
report in a letter to National Park stakeholders.
At the time Mr Findlater said:
“2012 saw the first full season of operation of byelaws on
east Loch Lomond relating to public consumption of alcohol and informal
camping. These continued to have the positive effect of supporting considerable
investment by partners that was designed to minimise and mitigate against those
that were behaving in an irresponsible manner. The area of east Loch Lomond saw
a 50% reduction in calls relating to antisocial behaviour and a staggering
81.5% reduction of recorded asb [anti-social behaviour] crimes.”
There has been some comment on social media by significant
commentators such as Cameron McNeish on the proposals which in places both
misrepresent the Park’s intentions and the extent of the efforts to date to
tackle the problems on the ground.
Full details are available at www.thisisyourpark.org.uk<http://www.thisisyourpark.org.uk> where people can also officially
record their views.
Pictures of some of the evidence of damage that has been collected is available
at
http://www.flickr.com/thisisyourpark
Dedicated social media
pages have been set up at;
www.twitter.com/yourparktweets
www.facebook.com/thisisyourpark
www.flickr.com/thisisyourpark
www.youtube.com/thisisyourpark
The National Park
stretches for more than 720 square miles and features the largest stretch of
inland water in Britain, Loch Lomond.
Loch Lomond & The
Trossachs National Park was formed in 2002 and outlines four key aims in its
National Partnership Plan 2012 – 2017;
·
To
conserve and enhance the natural and cultural heritage of the area;
·
To
promote sustainable use of the area’s natural resources;
·
To
promote understanding and enjoyment – including enjoyment in the form of
recreation - of the special qualities of the area;
·
To
promote sustainable economic and social development of the area’s communities